Digital Pedagogy

PianoWorld.com Forum Video Piano Lesson Help: Fingering Thirds in Canon in D

"Nancy W" in the PianoWorld.com forum's Adult Beginner section posted a question asking for help fingering double notes (thirds) in Dan Coates' arrangement of Pachabel's Canon in D major. In this video lesson, I try to analyze the passage and explain why she might be having difficulty, then offer two fingerings - one that's relatively easy to implement, the other rather exotic (but kind of fun if you like to try unusual fingerings!) I wasn't able to find a digital download version of the score, but I was able to transcribe it from a YouTube video into MuseScore, a terrific open source notation program (http://www.musescore.org/)

JavaScript is disabled!
To display this content, you need a JavaScript capable browser.

To purchase a copy of the score, please click the MusicNotes.com link below:

Power Piano Playing in 6 Years

I was delighted to find the source quote for an old axim that I had heard and experienced many times over in Rabbi Daniel Lapin's excellent book, "Thou Shall Prosper":

I have learned much from my teachers, even more from my colleagues, but I have learned most by far from my students.

- Rabbi Hanina

This has certainly been the case thanks to the wonderful time I spent with the Piano Studies students at Strings International Music Festival earlier in June.  One student in particular (well, her mother actually) posed one of the best questions I've ever fielded:  Starting from "ground zero", what's the best technical regimen for piano students who are serious about training to get into the top music conservatories like Curtis and Juilliard?

Here's a 6 year "power piano" program based on the technique books I studied myself to help develop a terrific foundation and strong fingers capable of independant dexterity.  It begins with some mind-numbing repetition exercises for the first 2-3 years, then shifts to more "musically-based" etudes, ending with some real gems of the repertoire.  By no means is this the only method out there, but having been personally called to jump in to "rescue" concerts at the last minute, I've gone to my old teacher (Mrs. Eleanor Sokoloff, who still calls me "Hughie" to this day...sigh...) and thanked her repeatedly for pounding these techniques into me as a young lad, equipping me to be able to tackle the most difficult technical challenges on a moment's notice.

The source for the majority of these scores is IMSLP.org and are provided here in the MusicReader file format.  For other sources, links are provided.

A disclaimer:  PLEASE BE CAREFUL AND WORK UNDER THE SUPERVISION OF A PROFESSIONAL PIANO TEACHER!  Some of these exercises can really hurt your hands/fingers if you don't know what you're doing - just as you wouldn't try benching 300 pounds from the get-go without proper training and spotting, the same needs to apply for going through these exercise regimens.  We forget how similar piano playing is to sports sometimes, and can neglect the proper muscle care needed to ensure proper strength training and maximum flexibility if we're not careful.

Year 1:  Scales, Arpeggios, and The Little Pischna by Bernard Wolff

The source for this copy of The Little Pischna comes from a Microsoft scan of an old, yellowed score at the New York Public Library at Lincoln Center.  The Internet Archive lists it as being "Not in Copyright", so I'm going to take them at their word.   Due to the poor quality of the scan, I'm including both the MusicReader version and the link to the original PDF source on the Internet Archive page:

The Little Pischna - MusicReader version

The Little Pischna - Link to Internet Archive Page

Last pages contain fingerings for all major, minor melodic/natural and minor harmonic scales.  Arpeggio exercises comprise the last portion of the book.  Scales in all keys should be learned within 1-2 years.  The 48 "regular" exercises in this book can be covered at the rate of approximately 1 per week, with allowances to stretch out the remainder of the year as needed.

Year 2: The "Big" Pischna - 60 Progressive Exercises

There is a PDF copy floating around on a Korean site, but I suspect that it's copyright status might be dubious at best in that form.  Better source would be to purchase both volumes from EveryNote.com (which has a strange spelling for Pischna:  "Pischina":

Pischna's 60 Progressive Exercises, Volumes 1 and 2 at EveryNote.com

This is the "Arnold Schwarzenegger" of strength-building exercise books.  Many long and frustrating hours of sweat and tears stained the keys of my old Steinway L getting through this torture manual.  Boy, am I glad I had this as part of my training!

If you're interested in getting through this at the pace of 1 per week, feel free to skip similar exercises, but try to get through the bulk of the material.  You'll be able to crush walnuts with your fingers after getting through this book.

Year 3: Joseffy and Moszkowski

Our next stop on the torture train is Joseffy's "School of Advanced Piano Playing".  This book contains my all-time favoritest, most diabolical exercise set:  trills for all adjacent finger pairs.  Try the one for the 4th and 5th fingers - you will cry.

Joseffy School of Advanced Piano Playing - MusicReader version

Joseffy School of Advanced Piano Playing - PDF

Now we finally get to exercises that start to sound like actual music with Moszkowski's 15 Etudes de Virtuosité, Op.72.  Lots of fun finger twisters and virtuosity builders.

Moszkowski 15 Etudes de Virtuosité, Op.72 - MusicReader version

Moszkowski 15 Etudes de Virtuosité, Op.72 - PDF

Year 4: Chopin Etudes Op. 10 and Op. 25

These are among the most beautiful - and challenging - concert etudes out there.  By no means is one expected to learn all 24 in just one year - either select a few favorites with the help of a teacher, or just enjoy taking your time working through these.  A wide variety of technical situations are covered, from velociraptor runs to that nasty etude in thirds, the infamous black key etude, and so many many more.

Chopin Etudes Op. 10 and Op. 25 - MusicReader version

Chopin Etudes Op. 10 and Op. 25 - PDF

Year 5: Liszt Part 1

With Liszt, the etude form is presented on the concert stage in grand form.  Here are the 3 concert etudes, as well as the 6 etudes based on themes by Paganini (my favorite being the last one in A minor).

Liszt 3 Concert Etudes - MusicReader version

Liszt 3 Concert Etudes - PDF

Liszt Grandes Études de Paganini - MusicReader version

Liszt Grandes Études de Paganini - PDF

Year 6: Liszt Part 2 and Debussy

In this final year, we tackle the fearsome Transcendental etudes by Liszt, and get introduced to an entirely new harmonic world with Debussy's 2 books of 12 etudes.

Liszt Transcendental Etudes - MusicReader version

Liszt Transcendental Etudes - PDF

Debusy Etudes Book 1 and 2 - MusicReader version

Debusy Etudes Book 1 and 2 - PDF

A Daily Breakdown

One other terrific question from the same mother was regarding a recommended daily technical routine to aim for.  This really depends on the discipline and motivation of the student, but assuming all batteries are charged to capacity, I would recommend all scales and arpeggios to start with once they're all properly learned (i used to read comic books during my S & A's, but please don't follow my bad example!!).  Final target metronome speed might be somewhere around 160 4 notes per tick, but feel free to play faster if you can ensure consistent accuracy.  All told, they should take up around 10 minutes minutes at the most.  Another 10 to 20  minutes working through a technique book like Joseffy or Pischna would round out the warmup/strength training portion.  Total for the warmup/strength training: 20-30 minutes.

Once the student has advanced to the Moszkowski etudes or Year 4+ repertoire, then an additional 30 to 40 minutes might then be spent applied to a concert etude from the Chopin, Liszt or Debussy collections.  These would require full focus and attention, and perhaps strategic practicing to isolate and iron out problem spots.  Total minimum daily time for warmups and advanced technique:  1 hour. Feel free to increase as needed.

Don't get in a tizzy if you don't get to cover every last etude volume cover to cover - I've actually only touched on a few of the Liszt etudes myself, and never actually worked on the Debussy at all (but they look so intruiguing!).  Even if you only get through a handful of these powerhouse pieces, your fingers will be stronger and more dextrous than ever.

If you have any other suggested methods that you'd like to share, leave a comment below!

A Video Screencast Tool for Music Lessons

A Video Screencast LessonOne of the most effective digital teaching/learning tools is the screencast, which is essentially a video capturing the activity from a computer screen.  You see where the mouse moves and clicks, watch words being typed, and can listen to an audio narrative explaining what's happening.  For examples of screencast tutorials, you can check out the growing library in our Learn section.

Camtasia Studio is perhaps the most popular screencast creation application currently available for both Mac and PC, and does a fine job if you stick to screen captures and audio narratives.  The big sticking point with Camtasia comes when you try to integrate live video simultaneously with the screencast - after about 5 or 10 minutes, the audio and video signals start to drift out of sync, getting progressively worse the longer the video runs.  As of this writing, Camtasia Studio 6 still doesn't appear to correct this issue.

I've made it a standard practice to provide videos of all of my students' lessons, using my Acer Aspier One Netbook's webcam for quick and easy footage.  For some time, though, i had been hoping to integrate both video and screencasts together, where the student could watch me mark digital scores in real time as they played.  As typical piano lessons run at least an hour or more in length, Camtasia just doesn't cut it with its audio/video sync issues.  After scouring online tech support forums, i came across a nifty screencast utility made in the UK called BB Flashback Pro.  This appears to be the only screencast creation utility that I've been able to find that can effectively keep audio, video, and screencast footage all perfectly synchronized even with footage up to 90 minutes in length.

Working with the students at this year's Strings International Piano Studies program was the perfect testing ground to work out the kinks and find the optimal settings to run BB Flashback Pro, MusicReader, and my old Panasonic Camcorder set to Webcam mode on my HP laptop.  It turns out that to prevent memory bottlenecks, the screen resolution should be set to 640x480 pixels (BB Flashback Pro can set that automatically), and MusicReader set to half-page view in order for the notes to be legible in a smaller video window.  The webcam footage will take up half the screen, so the trick is to resize the MusicReader window to approximately half the screen size.  You half to be careful, though - too much window resizing will cause BB Flashback Pro to freeze up, requiring a hard reboot of your computer.

Here's an example of BB Flashback being used to capture video footage of a piano lesson together with a screencast of MusicReader being used to annotate the score as the student plays:

JavaScript is disabled!
To display this content, you need a JavaScript capable browser.

BB Flashback Pro gives you the option to export your movies to Flash, Quicktime, and WMV file formats for optimal web viewing, in addition to AVI, Standalone EXE, and PowerPoint files with the movie embedded in the first slide.  Flash files are the most universal for web viewing (YouTube videos are all converted flash flv files), but unfortunately they tend to be pretty large.  WMV files seem to compress to the smallest sizes, but this Windows-based video format may not be as widely viewable on computers with different OS's.

You can add text boxes, buttons, and other graphic elements to your screencast movies, along with multiple audio tracks.  You can splice and edit down to the frame level for maximum control.

I'm really hoping BB Flashback Pro will add the option to move the webcam video beside the screencast window as opposed to its current picture-in-picture mode.  You can export the webcam video and the screencast as 2 separate files, but that kind of defeats the point of having them created simultaneously, and adds another hassle level to creating a finished clip, especially if you're working with a large number of files.

At $199, BB Flashback Pro isn't cheap, but then again not quite as expensive as Camtasia Studio which can run approximately $324 for a single license.  One more potential drawback is the fact that BB Flashback Pro currently only runs on Windows computers.  While not as slick as Camtasia Studio and lacking some bells and whistles, BB Flashback Pro is the only game in town that i know of when it comes to creating webcam, screencast, and audio content that stays synchronized for practical lengths of time.  I'm a little surprised that I haven't come across more reviews of this excellent program, even with its warts, as it really deserves much more attention and accolades for what it does well.